I couldn’t help but relate to Julia in Black Swan Green, as she is in nearly the same situation as I am now. I’ll try to use some of my experiences to help explain what Julia might be feeling, and how her character develops from the beginning to the end of the novel. Of course, I’m not her, so I can’t say for sure what’s on her mind.
My little brother is three years old, not thirteen like Jason. His name is Jake and he’s a whole lot of fun! I think we fail to embody the stereotypical sibling dynamics that Julia and Jason do because of our relative distance in age. I am more like a cool aunt than a big sister, I think. Nevertheless, I will have my early-novel Julia moments where I’ll catch Jake being a little stinker and have to lay down the law. How much Jake looks up to me is similar to Jason’s admiration of Julia. It's an amazing feeling to be a role model for a little kid. I’m not sure is Julia finds the same satisfaction in being so cool to Jason, but I think it is rewarding to be inspiring to anyone.
I think another part of what make Julia relatable is how she is able to talk back to her parents, and how Jason finds that so incredible. I am at a time in my life where I have just crossed the back-talk threshold and I can finally have a say and effectively defend myself in family situations. I think it's totally awesome and I still can’t believe it sometimes. Maybe part of why Julia sasses Uncle Brian so much is that she is finally permitted to go nuts at the dinner table without consequences. Maybe she endured years of listening to Uncle Brian’s weirdo rants and realized she could say something about it. Coincidentally, I have a grandfather named Brian and he thinks Barack Obama is a reincarnated ancient Egyptian pharaoh, and a lizard man, so I get to have my own fun on the holidays.
By the late chapters in the novel, Julia is in college and she has cleaned her hands of a consistent daily interaction with Jason. This development in their relationship has allowed Julia to bypass the constant strain that comes with a nosy little brother in order to become a helpful and protective authority for Jason. Although I am not yet in college, I am no longer required to babysit daily. Which is super nice. As a result of this, I no longer have the stress associated with interacting with Jake. There’s not a whole lot of emotional support I can offer a three-year-old who likes letters and the planets, but I find myself being an advocate for him much more! More than that, when I do babysit, we have much more fun because it becomes a special occasion. I guess the parallel here is a little strained since there’s not very many toddler dances in our area, and Jake doesn’t need to pop off on some tots in order to win the girl. That would be wild.
The point is that Julia kept me thinking of my own family situation. I wonder if maybe you felt the same. How do you relate to Julia? Do you think she is a good big sister? I think she is, but maybe that’s because I’m a lot like her.
I really appreciate the way you described Julia's responses to Brian not as "teenage sass" but, more so, as her standing her ground. I definitely found myself relating to Jason in my own PAST, but I thought Julia was particularly fun to read about because I feel her a lot right now, being in such a similar position in my life. It's funny to see this dynamic, too, because I have and older BROTHER, and I'd say our dynamic is a lot different than and older sister-young brother one.
ReplyDeleteI think one of the most touching aspects of Black Swan Green is the relationship between Julia and Jason. While at the beginning it seems like they have their ups and downs, they are united by their care for Mom and Dad's relationship. As Julia leaves for college, Jason really does feel torn between both of them, with Julia there to understand what it's like.
ReplyDeleteI can relate to Julia, but I also can't. I'm the youngest of three children and my siblings are both much older than me so I've always been the kind of timid one that goes along with everyone else. In this way, I guess I could relate more to Jason because I remember looking up to my sister in awe that she dared to challenge my dad.
ReplyDeletePersonally, as the oldest with three little siblings, I also definitely identify with Julia. One of my little sisters is a lot like me and i can tell she looks up to me a ton, and on one hand it's really cool and i love being able to be a role model but on the other it's kinda annoying having someone follow you so closely. So I totally get Julia's simultaneous annoyance with Jason and desire to take him under her wing. I'm really glad that as the book progressed their relationship grew. Nice post- i liked getting to hear someone else's perspective on the family dynamic.
ReplyDelete